Jump to content

Talk:Jonathan Pollard

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Pollard sold US secrets to many entities, not just Israel

[edit]

Whoever wrote this Wiki article on Jonathan Pollard deliberately falsified essential facts surrounding Pollard's arrest and imprisonment. He stole tens of thousands of highly classified documents and he sought out buyers around the country, around trhe world, long before trying to sell documents to Israel. This ridiculous and deliberately falsified notion that Pollard committed espionage in order to protect "America's ally" Israel, is ridiculous. Pollard was out to enrich himself, and he received large amounts of money from several entities, not just Israel. And Israel itself has long been known to spy on the US. AIPAC's own Larry Franklin came close to being jailed for life. The ADL was caught in a huge espionage scandal and was forced to pay out large sums of restitution to American victims in order to avoid prosecution. After Pollard was released from a cushy medium security prison, and house arrest, notorious Zionist Sheldon Adelson sent his luxury jet to pick up Pollard and his wife and fly them directly to Israel, where Netanyahoo greeted them at the airport in Tel Aviv. 50.27.254.128 (talk) 15:56, 5 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

First paragraph has an omission that jumps of the page

[edit]

As of the date/time of this talk-page edit the first paragraph of this article begins "Jonathan Jay Pollard (born August 7, 1954) is a former intelligence analyst for the US government. In 1984, Pollard sold numerous closely guarded state secrets, including the National Security Agency's ten-volume manual on how the U.S. gathers its signal intelligence, and disclosed the names of thousands of people who had cooperated with U.S. intelligence agencies". The omission is glaring. Presumably if Person A sells something, then there is some greater-than-50-50 chance that another party was the Buyer of what Person A sold. To whom did Pollard sell these secrets? To whom did he sell out the U.S.'s helpers? The ground? The sky? Birds chirping in trees? In-between "Pollard sold" and "numerous closely guarded state secrets", text is missing and it can't be for any legitimate reason. If the missing text is ", to Israel", then the deletion exists so that the reader will, by default, assume that Pollard betrayed the U.S.A. to the Soviets, and will regard Pollard in a more negative light than if the reader learns that Pollard betrayed the U.S.A. to a staunch U.S.A. ally. If, on the other hand, the missing text is something like "variously, to Israel, to the Soviets, and possibly to other countries" then the text has been deleted for the purpose of showing Pollard in a BETTER light, i.e. to avoid dislodging a reader's belief that Pollard cooperated ONLY with staunch U.S.A. ally Israel and had benign motives. I don't know what the missing text should be because I don't know all the facts. (If I knew all the facts, would I be reading on-line encyclopedias?) But either way, text is missing, either to make Pollard look worse or to make him look better. It is "spin". Pollard sold something. That means he sold it TO someone. Yet Wikipedia doesn't say (in the quoted beginning of this article) TO WHOM he sold, and, worse, thinks nobody's going to notice that Wikipedia has omitted the "to whom". (Another possible nefarious reason to omit the "to whom", if indeed (I don't know) the missing "to whom" is Israel, is to avoid showing ISRAEL in a negative light by allowing the reader to hold onto their default assumption that the missing "to whom" is the Soviets. But again, that would still be a lie by omission.)2600:1700:6759:B000:511D:59D7:1BE7:EAEF (talk) 02:17, 9 April 2023 (UTC)Christopher Lawrence Simpson[reply]

@Iskandar323: I don’t see anything nefarious, but I think the IP is talking about your recent edit here. -Location (talk) 03:07, 9 April 2023 (UTC)[reply]